Projects / PIR vs microwave vs radar comparison

PIR vs microwave vs radar comparison

Intermediate2.5 hGuided buildReviewed

Build it step by step

0 of 7 done
  1. ESP32

    Wire the three sensors

    Check each alone first.

  2. ESP3214.0 mASSD1306

    Run the OLED display

    Check the live states.

  3. ESP32

    Mount them side by side

    Same direction.

  4. ESP32

    Walk across the room

    Note the counts.

  5. ESP32

    Sit still for two minutes

    Which one holds on.

  6. ESP32

    Test through glass and with a fan

    Which one false-triggers.

  7. ESP32

    Write a results table

    Pick the best for each job.

In short

How do you build a PIR vs microwave vs radar comparison?

Test three motion sensors side by side with the same moves to see which is best for each job. You need ESP32 DevKit V1, PIR Motion Sensor HC-SR501, RCWL-0516 microwave radar motion sensor, LD2410 24 GHz human presence radar and SSD1306 OLED Display. It takes 7 steps and about 150 minutes.

Level
Intermediate
Time
About 150 min
Parts
5

Parts list

Tick what you already own. It saves to My Garage, so “Build with what I have” knows.

Wiring

FromToWhy
PIR OUTESP32 GPIO32PIR signal (the PIR needs 5 V)
RCWL-0516 OUTESP32 GPIO33Microwave signal (3.3 V output)
LD2410 OUTESP32 GPIO25Radar presence signal (3.3 V output)
PIR, RCWL-0516 and LD2410 VCC and GNDESP32 VIN (5 V) and GNDPower
OLED SDA and SCLESP32 GPIO21 and GPIO22I2C display
OLED VCC and GNDESP32 3V3 and GNDPower

Code

A PIR sees changes in heat as a warm body moves across its field, an RCWL-0516 sends out a microwave signal and notices any movement that changes the echo, and the LD2410 is a 24 GHz radar that can tell a still person from an empty room. Each behaves differently in practice: PIRs miss people sitting still and can be fooled by sun and heaters; the RCWL-0516 sees through thin walls and glass and may trigger on fans or nearby wires; the LD2410 is the most reliable for presence but needs 5 V and costs more. Mount all three side by side pointing the same way and run the same tests for each: walk across, walk towards, sit still for two minutes, wave a hand, stand behind a glass pane, and switch on a fan. Count how many triggers each gives and write the results in a table. The counts on the screen only grow, so power cycle between tests. The three sensors work at the same time, and the RCWL-0516 can interfere with the LD2410, so try a gap of several centimetres. Pick the sensor by the job: PIR for cheap battery use, radar when someone must be detected sitting still.

Runs on a virtual ESP32 Dev Module in your browser, with sliders for the sensors. Happy with it? Verify and upload to your real board from the same page (Chrome or Edge on a computer).

// Motion sensor comparison: counts each sensor's triggers and shows the live state, so you can run the same tests on all three.
// Libraries: Adafruit SSD1306, Adafruit GFX. Board: ESP32. Also prints CSV lines to the serial monitor for a spreadsheet.
#include <Wire.h>
#include <Adafruit_GFX.h>
#include <Adafruit_SSD1306.h>
Adafruit_SSD1306 oled(128, 64, &Wire, -1);
const uint8_t PINS[3] = { 32, 33, 25 };
const char* NAMES[3] = { "PIR  ", "RCWL ", "LD2410" };
int counts[3] = { 0, 0, 0 };
bool last[3] = { false, false, false };
void setup() {
  Serial.begin(115200);
  for (int i = 0; i < 3; i++) pinMode(PINS[i], INPUT);
  oled.begin(SSD1306_SWITCHCAPVCC, 0x3C);
  oled.setTextColor(SSD1306_WHITE);
  Serial.println("ms,sensor,state");
}
void loop() {
  for (int i = 0; i < 3; i++) {
    bool now = digitalRead(PINS[i]) == HIGH;
    if (now != last[i]) {
      if (now) counts[i]++;
      Serial.print(millis()); Serial.print(','); Serial.print(NAMES[i]); Serial.print(','); Serial.println(now);
      last[i] = now;
    }
  }
  oled.clearDisplay(); oled.setTextSize(1);
  for (int i = 0; i < 3; i++) {
    oled.setCursor(0, i * 16);
    oled.print(NAMES[i]); oled.print(last[i] ? " ON  " : " off "); oled.print(counts[i]);
  }
  oled.display();
  delay(20);
}

What the serial monitor should show

Open the serial monitor at the baud rate in the code. This is what our simulator prints for a virtual ESP32 Dev Module with its sensors at their default values. Your numbers will follow your real readings, but the format should match.

ms,sensor,state

Test checklist

What you should see at each check. If a reading is far off, stop and use the troubleshooting list.

CheckExpected
Walk pastAll three trigger
Sit still for 2 minutesLD2410 stays on, PIR drops off
Thin glass pane in betweenRCWL and radar still trigger, PIR does not
Fan switched onRCWL may trigger often

If it does not work

A sensor never triggers

Check its power (5 V) and the signal pin.

Everything triggers all the time

Move the sensors apart and away from the fan or router.

OLED blank

Check the I2C address.

Still stuck? Find the fault step by step with your multimeter →

Ask Lark AI

Common questions

What parts do I need for the PIR vs microwave vs radar comparison?

ESP32 DevKit V1, PIR Motion Sensor HC-SR501, RCWL-0516 microwave radar motion sensor, LD2410 24 GHz human presence radar and SSD1306 OLED Display.

How long does the PIR vs microwave vs radar comparison take to build?

About 150 minutes for a intermediate maker, in 7 steps.

How do I know the PIR vs microwave vs radar comparison works?

Walk past: All three trigger. Sit still for 2 minutes: LD2410 stays on, PIR drops off. Thin glass pane in between: RCWL and radar still trigger, PIR does not.

A sensor never triggers: what should I check?

Check its power (5 V) and the signal pin.

Everything triggers all the time: what should I check?

Move the sensors apart and away from the fan or router.

OLED blank: what should I check?

Check the I2C address.