Projects / Compare AA battery types

Compare AA battery types

Beginner4 hGuided buildReviewed

Build it step by step

0 of 8 done
  1. NANOINA2191.38 A

    Wire the INA219

    Check it reads a cell voltage with the load off.

  2. NANOIRLZ44

    Add the load switch

    Wire the MOSFET and 10 Ω resistor.

  3. NANOINA2191.39 A

    Test with a short run

    Run for a minute and check current is about 150 mA.

  4. NANO+INA2191.39 A

    Run the alkaline cell

    Save the CSV from the serial monitor.

  5. NANO+

    Run the NiMH cell

    Use a fully charged cell and repeat.

  6. NANO+

    Compare

    Plot voltage against time and compare the mAh.

  7. NANO

    Note the end point

    See how each cell's voltage falls near the end.

  8. NANO+

    Recycle spent cells

    Take them to a battery recycling point.

In short

How do you build a compare AA battery types?

Discharge alkaline and NiMH AAs at the same load and compare capacity and voltage curves. You need AA alkaline battery, AA NiMH rechargeable 2000 mAh, INA219 Current Monitor, Arduino Nano, Resistor 10 Ω, MOSFET IRLZ44N, Resistor 10 kΩ, Resistor 220 Ω, Breadboard 830 Tie Points and Jumper wires male to male (40 pcs, 20 cm). It takes 8 steps and about 240 minutes.

Level
Beginner
Time
About 240 min
Parts
10

Parts list

Tick what you already own. It saves to My Garage, so “Build with what I have” knows.

Wiring

FromToWhy
INA219 VCCNano 5VPower
INA219 GNDNano GNDGround
INA219 SDANano A4I2C data
INA219 SCLNano A5I2C clock
Cell +INA219 VIN+High-side current sense
INA219 VIN-10 Ω resistor then IRLZ44N drainLoad path
IRLZ44N sourceCell - and Nano GNDCommon ground
Nano D5220 Ω resistor then IRLZ44N gateSwitches the load
10 kΩ resistorIRLZ44N gate and groundPull-down so the load is off at reset

Code

Test only single AA cells, one type at a time, with the same 10 Ω load, which draws about 150 mA at 1.5 V and gives the resistor about 0.2 W, so use a resistor rated 0.5 W or more and expect it to feel warm. Do not test damaged cells, lithium-ion cells or anything but AA alkaline and NiMH here. Discharging stops at 0.9 V, the usual end point; going lower can damage rechargeable cells. A 2000 mAh NiMH cell should give roughly 1700 to 2000 mAh at this load and an alkaline cell often a little less at the same current, with a falling voltage curve. Run the test in a safe place and do not leave it overnight unwatched; the MOSFET switches the load off at the end. Take the cell out when finished. Arduino IDE, board "Arduino Nano" (processor ATmega328P, or ATmega328P (Old Bootloader) for clones).

Runs on a virtual Arduino Nano in your browser, with sliders for the sensors. Happy with it? Verify and upload to your real board from the same page (Chrome or Edge on a computer).

// Library: Adafruit INA219. Logs time, volts, mA and mAh every 10 seconds, stops at 0.9 V.
#include <Wire.h>
#include <Adafruit_INA219.h>

Adafruit_INA219 ina;
const byte LOAD = 5;
const float CUTOFF_V = 0.9;
float mah = 0;
unsigned long last, startMs;
bool running = true;

void setup() {
  Serial.begin(9600);
  pinMode(LOAD, OUTPUT); digitalWrite(LOAD, LOW);
  if (!ina.begin()) { Serial.println("INA219 not found"); while (1) {} }
  Serial.println("seconds,volts,ma,mah");
  digitalWrite(LOAD, HIGH);
  startMs = last = millis();
}

void loop() {
  if (!running) return;
  unsigned long now = millis();
  if (now - last >= 10000) {
    float dt = now - last; last = now;
    float v = ina.getBusVoltage_V();
    float ma = ina.getCurrent_mA();
    mah += ma * dt / 3600000.0;                 // milliamps times hours
    Serial.print((now - startMs) / 1000); Serial.print(",");
    Serial.print(v, 3); Serial.print(","); Serial.print(ma, 1); Serial.print(",");
    Serial.println(mah, 1);
    if (v < CUTOFF_V) {
      digitalWrite(LOAD, LOW);                   // stop the discharge
      running = false;
      Serial.println("done");
    }
  }
}

What the serial monitor should show

Open the serial monitor at the baud rate in the code. This is what our simulator prints for a virtual Arduino Nano with its sensors at their default values. Your numbers will follow your real readings, but the format should match.

seconds,volts,ma,mah

Test checklist

What you should see at each check. If a reading is far off, stop and use the troubleshooting list.

CheckExpected
Load onAbout 150 mA from a fresh cell
Voltage curveNiMH flatter than alkaline
CapacityNiMH 1500 to 2000 mAh, alkaline 1500 to 2500 mAh depending on brand
EndLoad switches off at 0.9 V

If it does not work

INA219 not found

Check I2C wiring and power.

Current zero

Check the MOSFET gate and the load path.

Resistor very hot

Use a higher rating or a cell with lower voltage.

Capacity looks low

Check contacts and that the cell was fully charged.

Still stuck? Find the fault step by step with your multimeter →

Ask Lark AI

Common questions

What parts do I need for the compare AA battery types?

AA alkaline battery, AA NiMH rechargeable 2000 mAh, INA219 Current Monitor, Arduino Nano, Resistor 10 Ω, MOSFET IRLZ44N, Resistor 10 kΩ, Resistor 220 Ω, Breadboard 830 Tie Points and Jumper wires male to male (40 pcs, 20 cm).

How long does the compare AA battery types take to build?

About 240 minutes for a beginner maker, in 8 steps.

How do I know the compare AA battery types works?

Load on: About 150 mA from a fresh cell. Voltage curve: NiMH flatter than alkaline. Capacity: NiMH 1500 to 2000 mAh, alkaline 1500 to 2500 mAh depending on brand.

INA219 not found: what should I check?

Check I2C wiring and power.

Current zero: what should I check?

Check the MOSFET gate and the load path.

Resistor very hot: what should I check?

Use a higher rating or a cell with lower voltage.

Capacity looks low: what should I check?

Check contacts and that the cell was fully charged.